Caol Ila 15-year-old

Caol Ila

WB 86.9 166 оценок 55.2 %vol 15 лет

Refill AO Virgin AO finish Whiskybase

Бочки созревания/финиша

Выдержка Refill AO Hogshead / Virgin AO Finish · Whiskybase (Cask Type) · 2026-09-13T06:05:44Z WB ↗

Финиш Refill AO Hogshead / Virgin AO Finish · Whiskybase (Finishing) · 2026-09-13T06:05:44Z WB ↗

Магазинов с предложением: 1 · предложений: 1 · в наличии: 1 · цена: от 167.90 €

S3: собрано индивидуальных оценок 166 из 166

карточка Whiskybase

Отзывы Whiskybase

учтено 38 заметок · текстовых 22 · полнота WB не подтверждена (legacy wb_reviews: один автор — одна запись)

Суммаризация отзывов

Классический профиль Caol Ila — сухой торфяной дым, соль, море, цитрус и ваниль, поверх которых лежит финишная выдержка в свежем американском дубе. Опытные хвалят непривычную сладость и мягкость, остальные чаще спорят из-за навязчивого дуба и пряности.

развернуть подробно

В аромате — тёплый маслянистый торфяной дым, сушёные водоросли, солёный морской воздух и запах костра на пляже, поверх которых ваниль, подпалённая карамель, зелёные яблоки, цитрус и копчёные тропические фрукты; у многих проскакивает минеральная, йодистая, почти лафройговская нота и лёгкий «грязный» оттенок машинного масла. Во вкусе структура плотная, маслянистая: копчёные абрикос и персик, соль, минеральность, ваниль и карамель соседствуют с чёрным перцем, имбирём, гвоздикой, лакрицей и заметной сухостью дуба; послевкусие обычно долгое, сухо-дубовое и перечное, но со сладким ванильно-цитрусовым, выпечечно-карамельным поворотом от финишной бочки. Опытные ревьюеры настроены благосклоннее: отмечают нехарактерную для этого розлива сладость и фруктовость, хорошо интегрированный спирт и осторожно выполненный финиш, ставя в основном 85–89. Возражения концентрируются вокруг свежего дуба и пряности: их называют несбалансированными, навязчивыми, придающими вкусу химозный, клеевой или горьковатый оттенок, а крепость 55% — избыточной и жгучей; кто-то говорит о «неудавшейся интеграции» маслянистого дистиллята и опилок и о том, что независимые розливы дешевле и не хуже. Оценки при этом кучные (в основном 83–89), расхождение не в баллах, а в трактовке: удачная провокационная фестивальная работа против переоценённого розлива, испорченного девственным дубом; выпадают лишь пара восторженных 96 за баланс дыма и хереса.

собрано 22/38 текстовых отзывов · полнота WB не подтверждена (собрано локально) · 2026-07-21 14:52:40 · источник wb_whiskies (историческое поле, без evidence)

Fight65 Connoisseur 88 01 jul 2022 10:20 pm

нос 88 · вкус 88 · финиш 87

robse211 Expert Senior 88 02 oct 2022 8:35 am

нос 89 · вкус 88 · финиш 88

MaltsofIslay Expert Senior 89 03 aug 2022 10:02 am

Very tasty Caol IIa with an emphatically fruity side with light citrus notes, some orange zest and oak. No disturbing bitter tones and the alcohol is very well integrated! The 15 years of maturation has made it significantly milder and fruitier than the Lagavulin Feis 2022 with the same barrel combination that was tried in comparison!

нос 88 · вкус 89 · финиш 89

EvilAFI Connoisseur 88 04 jan 2024 4:04 am

This vo finish works well here, sweet, smoky, spicy, vanilla, touch of glue but in a good way

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	89	Clean smoke, bbq ribs, tinned fruit salad, vanilla
Вкус	88	Caramel, oak, touch of glue, nice spice mix of red and black pepper
Финиш	87	Char, oak, chewy, varnish

butt Connoisseur 88 06 may 2023 11:19 am

нос 88 · вкус 89 · финиш 86

Glenrothes1973 Connoisseur 86 06 oct 2024 9:56 pm

нос 85 · вкус 86 · финиш 87

Saftkenner Connoisseur 89 07 aug 2022 5:29 pm

A really well-done festival bottling, which is also painfully high-priced, but ultimately is a lot more fun than this year's Fèis Ìle-Lagavulin, which only has 12 Lenze, but is priced at the same level.

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	89	The powerful and also extremely multifaceted smoke note is particularly noteworthy here at the beginning. On the one hand, it shows itself with a very nice maritime note in the direction of a fresh sea breeze (mineral, salty, iodine-rich), and on the other hand, it takes you to a historic half-timbered farmhouse, in which a fireplace blazes happily and smoke clouds the whole room, and also the antique furniture, wrapped - and whoops, someone even crumbled a pinch of dry leaves into the fire... very nice impressions. There is also a good portion of vanilla, slightly scorched caramel, malt beer, softened apples, candied lemons, honey, a hint of oak spice and finally a wonderfully dirty note in the direction of motor oil. It tolerates heat extremely well and ensures that it opens even further and releases more and more aromas. At the end there is an exotic, creamy aroma that reminds me of soft ice cream with passion fruit syrup.
Вкус	90	Oh yes, he can keep up on the palate. Powerful attack, flatters and wets the palate with a pleasantly oily layer. The smoke is by no means impetuous here, but has an almost polished and composed-looking character, so that it can resonate with the other aromas, light-footed, spiciness-giving and enriching. In addition liquid caramel, charred wood, sea water (mineral-salty), a pinch of iodine (direction Laphroaig, only a little more elegant), full porridge passion fruit, vanilla, pound cake with lemon aroma, tender oak.
Финиш	88	Mid-length finish. Amazingly accommodating. Hardly any smoke here, but rather sweet in the direction of vanilla, pastries, salty caramel, juicy lemon cake.

faarndt Member Senior 87 07 feb 2026 11:31 pm

toller Coal Ila, schöne Fruchtnoten, wenig komplex

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	88	klassische Coal Ila Noten gepaar mit Dosen Ananas, leichte Nussnote, Apfel und Birnen Noten
Вкус	87	mild, Vanille, leichte Eichenwürze
Финиш	85	mild, Alkohol gut eingebunden, wenig komplex

Horror_Vacui Expert Senior 87 08 aug 2022 9:20 pm

Nose: The nose is quite "OA-typical", a little closer to the 12 than the 18. That means: maritime, slightly dry smoke, burning algae on the beach. Green apples, a squeeze of lime. A quite strong vanilla and cinnamon impact, which at times reminds one more of apple crumble with sweet red apples and with vanilla sauce and cinnamon. With a little standing time, clove is added subliminally, as well as a hint of aniseed. Mouth: For 55% I find a pleasant start. The oak is present quite early and quite spicy. Here again carnation, anise. Citrus flavors, almond biscuits, crab chips and wakame (seaweed popularly used in seaweed salad) with sesame seeds. And above all, the vanilla is very present. At times, the maritime character gets lost a little in the tension between sweetness and spice. Finish: Medium length, slightly ashy, clear vanilla, white and green gummy bears. Striking oak. 87/100 Conclusion: A bottling that I personally don't like much. Unfortunately, for my taste, the combination of virgin American oak wood and this distillate does not go so well together. I find the carnation a bit out of place, the vanilla is too intrusive for me in places. I would like to emphasize positively, however, that the finish seems to have been carried out with caution. The fresh oak didn't iron everything down, especially on the nose I find it very representative of the OA's in the first few minutes after pouring

90ClubWhisky Connoisseur 86 08 dec 2024 5:09 pm

Golden color. Oily structure.

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	85	Smoke. Citrus. Peat. Dry peat. Sea salt. Salted peanuts. Vanilla. Spices. Herbalism.
Вкус	87	Lots of salt. Citrus underneath and orchard fruit. Dry peat. Smoke. Minerality. Vanilla. Caramel. Salted caramel. Light oiliness. Spices. Ginger. Black pepper.
Финиш	87	Vanilla. Caramel. Orchard fruit. Red apples. Toffee. Spices. Black pepper. Slightly warming. Citrus. Long finish.

Ana Chronist Expert Senior 87 09 aug 2024 4:08 pm

нос 86 · вкус 87 · финиш 87

eselsim Expert Senior 85 09 nov 2024 8:42 pm

нос 85 · вкус 85 · финиш 84

Victor_Harri Expert Senior 83 09 oct 2024 11:02 am

They could have done better. This Cask combo will suit more the lovers of the smoke/sweet combination, more kind of Island style rather than Islay peat. The virgin oak finish stirs the mix one bit too uncontrollably... I expected more for a 15 y old festival edition, the quality goes down in the name of the demand and the (unknown) numbers of bottles... At least is all right for the price. Won it for a hundred quid.

Cubey666 Connoisseur 87 11 mar 2024 7:36 pm

Tasted during a sublime BYOB, the 18th of February 2023, in Hotel Haarhuis, Arnhem I wrote down just two words: "very nice!"

нос 86 · вкус 87 · финиш 87

whiskyaudiophile Expert Senior 83 12 feb 2026 10:28 pm

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	87	Quite peaty, vanilla, a bit of ash, mint, slight fruitiness, honey, fresh puff pastry, chlorinated pool. Alcohol is quite pronounced. After some time, a bit of ash disappears, and fruitiness is more pronounced (a bit of tropical fruits also). Interesting nose.
Вкус	81	Alcohol punch, smoke, vanilla, wet wood and cardboard, chilli peppers. Wow, alcohol is very strong in this one. It's quite creamy, but very spicy still after a few sips. There is also a constant bitterness that doesn't help with the flavor. So much worse than the nose.
Финиш	82	Wet cardboard, mint, peppers, bitterness, quite long but not in a good way. Little better that taste though.

grinface Connoisseur 85 12 nov 2022 11:43 pm

The spices and especially the oak seasoning bother me more than I would like. Otherwise it is a very clear Caol Ila profile. However, there are also significantly cheaper representatives of independent bottlers in the category. Full review in a flight of 8 Caol Ila: https://keinehalbendrinks.de/2022/10/06/ein-weiterer-besuch-bei-caol-ila/

Yuliyan78 Expert Senior 88 13 nov 2024 7:41 pm

нос 87 · вкус 88 · финиш 88

bobigr Expert Senior 87 13 nov 2024 7:59 pm

нос 87 · вкус 87 · финиш 88

LongPourAmourBlog Expert Senior 88 17 jun 2022 12:17 am

First whiff is definitely chalky, like wet pebbles on the beach. After a few moments a delicate peat influence takes center stage, with in the background a subtle meaty note. Every time I pick up the glass there is a new characteristic to be found. A smoky sweetness reveals itself. The constant development is amazing. Classic Caol Ila with an oily, mouth coating feel on the tongue. But also a raw side that I associate with the virgin oak. Like chewing on the sharp side of a chainsaw, the edges cutting deep. Forget Ziggy Stardust, this is Ziggy Sawdust. All in all it feels like failed integration. The oily liquid and the sawdust influence are in a fight, duality at its best. It makes for a complex and interesting drinking experience. Caol Ila succeeds in bottling an expression for the more experienced connoisseur. That is what a Feis Ile bottling should be about; to create discussion. The finish is all on wood but not too overpowering. The pleasant thing is: there is nothing exotic in it. It is clean refill wood Caol Ila, with on top a layer of extra clean new wood Caol Ila. No dirty notes from sherry or other (fortified) wine.

Sweetspot Connoisseur 85 18 dec 2023 2:31 pm

нос 86 · вкус 85 · финиш 83

Hvdree Connoisseur 87 19 feb 2023 1:36 pm

нос 88 · вкус 87 · финиш 86

JacobaEd Connoisseur 88 19 feb 2023 9:21 am

huangshantong Expert Senior 86 20 apr 2023 12:25 pm

↑↑↑ Click show in original language Calella is basically my favorite winery, and I was a little disappointed with my initial impressions of this wine. It's actually very winery, very Calrera, but it's very unbalanced.

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	86	Even under the premise that I like CI very much, it is still difficult for me to hide a certain degree of dissatisfaction with it; on the smell, it is really great and simple, with a rich malt aroma and a powdery powdery peat flavor After pairing it with the flavor brought by this virgin barrel, the result of the mixture is a little pungent, and even a little closer to those chemical raw materials that are not very comfortable.
Вкус	87	Fruity, malty and sweet, and peaty, but the feeling brought by this wine, the feeling brought by alcohol, is really a bit too much. I have always liked the sense of coordination, that is, the bodied wine, bursting alcohol, with a rich and complex flavor, which makes people aftertaste; the simple and refreshing flavor, with a light and comfortable wine body, makes people relaxed and happy. On the contrary, it just makes people feel very uncomfortable.
Финиш	86	unconcealable disappointment

el Gato Connoisseur 89 21 dec 2023 10:56 am

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	89	Marina. Salt and minerals. Smoked meat, bacon. Barbecue spices. Tool box. Dunnage warehouse. Dusty. Vanilla. Lemons. Mushrooms. Smoke and peat.
Вкус	89	Quite viscous. Herbs and salmiac. Meaty and slightly sour. Spices. Barbecue sauce. Oysters. Glazed and salty meat. Maritime. Peaty.
Финиш	88	Long. Herbs and anise lingering. Pastries. Sweet peat and subtle smoke. Lemons and salt. Spices, pepper. Caramel and chemical hints.

Whisky_dan Expert Senior 88 21 feb 2026 9:01 pm

нос 88 · вкус 88 · финиш 87

Archer Connoisseur 89 21 jan 2023 10:27 pm

Even if the nose and taste are absolutely typical for Caol Ila-OA, I can't remember ever having such a sweet OA-Caol Ila in my glass. Fascinating - and very tasty.

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	89	Warm, greasy peat smoke, dried seaweed, salty sea air, beach grass: I can't help but think of a summer evening on the beach here, campfire atmosphere, surf, the harbor not far away. Over the fire, tropical fruits on a skewer, warm caramel sweets, vanilla. An absolute feel-good nose.
Вкус	90	Very pleasant, in no way intrusive or burning start. Very dry right from the start, a dryness that I have found in many OA by Caol Ila and therefore consider it "classic". Smoked apricot and peach chunks, warm and spicy peat smoke, smoked ham, dried seaweed, some fresh tar, grated nutmeg, clove powder, pepper, vanilla. Very successful mixture of lightly smoked fruit on the one hand and spicy and maritime aromas on the other.
Финиш	88	Stays for a long time and also delivers a lot of vanilla in the finish. Dry wood to the end, but in the same form as at the beginning on the tongue, neither increasing nor decreasing. Sweet, tangy, peat-smoky fruits.

MichaMann Newbie 96 23 apr 2024 6:42 pm

The balance between smoke and sherry is very nice. Quite complex and rich

alex..w..fan Connoisseur 80 23 mar 2024 6:23 pm

21 20 19 20 80 Young pepper whisky, from the “can only be drunk on location” series.. And so you can drink it, and thank you for that, the only question is why?

minialkoff Connoisseur 84 23 mar 2024 8:24 pm

21+21+21+21

Schusti_94 Expert Senior 86 25 oct 2025 9:08 am

Unusually little cold ash for Caol Ila standards. Clearly more fruity, with notes of pear and mirabelle plum.

нос 86 · вкус 85 · финиш 86

Ozzyosbourne007 Expert Senior 86 26 aug 2025 9:11 pm

DramSlayer Connoisseur 88 26 nov 2023 6:21 pm

нос 87 · вкус 88 · финиш 88

magic_slim Connoisseur 86 27 jun 2023 10:32 pm

Color: Dark Gold

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	86	Intensively smoky and peaty at first nosing. In the back there is something lemony, maritim and mineral. After awhile I also get weak notes of cookie dough and apple juice. The alcohol is very good integrated.
Вкус	86	Powerful, spirity, spicy and peaty at first mouthfeel. Bold and dry with lots of peat when swallowed. Quite peppery, salty and spicy with licorice.
Финиш	85	Medium long. Dry, oaky and peppery. Remains pleasant.

Vas Connoisseur 88 28 aug 2023 6:19 am

нос 89 · вкус 88 · финиш 88

CATHPALUG Member Junior 96 28 aug 2025 6:14 am

very good islay

FeydRautha Connoisseur 89 30 jun 2022 11:56 pm

LordIslay Expert Senior 85 31 oct 2022 11:25 am

A solid Caol Ila, strong in taste. However, the 2020 Feis Ile was a lot better.

нос 85 · вкус 85 · финиш 86

Islaywolf Expert Senior 86 31 oct 2022 9:18 am

Typical Caol Ila.

нос 87 · вкус 86 · финиш 85

Оценки по участникам WB

собранные 87.0 среднее по всем сохранённым наблюдениям; WB-рейтинг не заменяется

снимок #12300 · статус complete · собран 2026-09-13T18:54:35+00:00 · сверено: строки сходятся с объявленным числом · ожидалось 166, фактических строк 166, сохранено 166

экспертный allowlist: Expert Junior, Expert Senior, Specialist, Connoisseur. Служебные роли (Administrator, Community Manager, Editor, Photo Moderator, Shoplink Moderator, Super Administrator) остаются ролью, но экспертизой не объявляются. Авторское смещение не применяется: author-bias correction not applied; view is raw observations.

показано 16 из 166 · страница 4 из 4 · за страницей ещё 150

Одно наблюдение = одна строка исходной таблицы; повторные оценки одного автора сохраняются. «Дата неизвестна» означает отсутствие даты в источнике, а не время сбора.
Автор	Роль WB	Эксперт	Оценка	Дата	Наблюдение
Mas40	Member Senior	нет	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #150
Udovitsa Andrey	Expert Senior	да	84.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #151
minialkoff	Connoisseur	да	84.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #152
Silurs Cache	Expert Senior	да	84.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #153
ganzspiht	Expert Junior	да	84.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #154
Tubesnake	Member Senior	нет	84.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #155
Jin_mk	Member Senior	нет	84.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #156
smogmonster	Expert Junior	да	84.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #157
Watson	Connoisseur	да	83.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #158
whiskyaudiophile	Expert Senior	да	83.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #159
Victor_Harri	Expert Senior	да	83.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #160
Dorain	Expert Senior	да	83.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #161
Oleg	Expert Senior	да	83.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #162
alex..w..fan	Connoisseur	да	80.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #163
Vale_Riano	Member Senior	нет	76.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #164
ben_a	Expert Senior	да	75.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #165

Роли в снимке (6)

Connoisseur: 57
Expert Junior: 21
Expert Senior: 65
Member Junior: 2
Member Senior: 19
Newbie: 2

Источник — append-only снимки S3 (core_vote_snapshot/core_vote_row). Режимы ничего не записывают: страница только читает и не запускает сбор.

Избранное	Бутылка	Цена	WB рейтинг	Регион / дистиллерия	Скидка	WA медиана	vs WA	Fair€	vs fair	Маркет WB	vs маркет	Наличие	Тип / объём	Магазин	WB связь
	Caol Ila 15-year-old 55.2% ABV Refill AO Virgin AO finish Whiskybase 70 cl	167.90 € 259.90 €	WB 86.9 166 оц. собр. 166/166	islaycaol ila	+35.4%	120.87 € 108.54 €–133.19 € · 2 из 5	-38.9%	121.00 €	-38.8%	182.45 €	+8.0%	в наличии склад: 5	—70 cl	Fine-Whisky	WB #209609 не подтверждено (не exact)